Susan came to Porter-Hay Insurance (Andalusia location) in January of 2019 after Porter-Hay Insurance acquired the Orville Minteer & Assoc. Agency, which she had been with for 18 years. Prior to that she had been with Country Insurance for 14 years. Susan grew up in Andalusia, raised 3 sons in the Rockridge district and now her grandchildren are being raised in the same district. She and her husband Dave reside in rural Milan. Their three sons, Eric(Val), Kyle(Erin), and Logan(Stephanie) and seven grandchildren all reside in Andalusia. In her spare time, she enjoys travel, yard work, decorating, jeepin’ with her husband and most of all spending time with family and grandchildren.


Kristen started with Porter Insurance in 2014. She lives just outside of Little York with her husband Lucas and 2 children Wyatt and Kaylee. In her spare time, she enjoys spending time with family, camping and baking.


Baily started working in insurance in 2021 as the receptionist for the agency. She graduated with an Associate’s Degree from Spoon River College in 2019. She lives in Rio with her boyfriend and two dogs. Outside of work she likes to cook, read and race demo derby cars in the summer.


In 2018, Shayla joined Porter-Hay team.  Formerly working in banking, like most people in the industry, she fell into insurance by chance/luck. Outside of work Shayla enjoys traveling, art and being outside.